10
Loading video...
By Paul Attaway
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The numbers should concern all of us. The American Psychological Association's 2025 Stress in America survey found that 62 percent of U.S. adults consider societal division a significant source of stress, while 54 percent say they often or sometimes feel isolated.
Among adults who identify societal division as a significant source of stress, that figure rises to 61 percent. Researchers at the University of California, Irvine, have also found that 37 percent of Americans reported experiencing a "political breakup," meaning they had lost a friendship, family relationship, romantic relationship or relationship with a coworker because of political differences. These figures tell me that our inability to listen to one another is no longer simply a problem with political debate. It is affecting how we relate to one another.
I don't believe America has lost its willingness to disagree. If anything, we have become exceptionally good at it. What I worry we have lost is something more important: the discipline to listen. Disagreement has always been part of American life. We argue about politics, religion, culture, economics, morality and the direction of the country.
Read More on Leadership Insights
Those disagreements are not inherently unhealthy. A society that cannot challenge its own assumptions cannot grow. But disagreement becomes destructive when the objective is no longer understanding. Too often, we enter conversations preparing our response before the other person has finished speaking. We are not listening to understand. We are listening for an opportunity to respond, correct, defeat or dismiss.
When Disagreement Becomes Competition
I have come to think of this as a kind of debate only culture. Communication increasingly feels like a competition, almost like a verbal game of ping pong. People feel that if they are not talking, they are not controlling the room. Everyone wants to get a point across, but fewer people seem interested in understanding what the person across from them is actually trying to say. The consequence is that disagreement becomes less about exchanging ideas and more about establishing who is right. Compromise begins to look like weakness, and asking questions can be mistaken for conceding an argument.
The problem extends beyond political conversations. When listening disappears, people become easier to categorize. A political position becomes an identity. A disagreement becomes evidence of someone's character. One mistake becomes the story we tell about that person forever.
We stop seeing the person and start seeing the label. Social media has made this tendency even harder to resist. Someone's worst moment can travel around the world in minutes, while the circumstances behind that moment may never travel with it. We have more information about one another than perhaps any generation before us, but I am not convinced we understand one another any better.
Why Context Matters
The reason is simple: understanding requires context, and context takes time. As a novelist, I have a particular advantage that we rarely have in everyday life. I can give my characters context before asking my readers to judge them. I can show the family that raised them. I can show poverty or privilege, loss, fear, ambition, resentment, love and insecurity. I can show the decisions that gradually turned a person into who they became. Real life rarely gives us that luxury. When we meet someone, we usually encounter a snapshot. We hear one opinion, see one reaction, read one social media post or witness one mistake. Then we make a judgment.
In real life, when we meet people, all too often, we don't want to know about them. We want to tell them about ourselves. We want to establish our position rather than understand theirs. That is where I believe fiction has something important to teach us. A novel forces us to stay with a person. It does not allow us to encounter a complicated character for five seconds, assign them a label and move on. We have to spend time with them. We see their contradictions. We learn their history. We discover what happened before the decision that initially made us judge them.
That does not mean we have to approve of them. It means we understand them. I have learned through writing that those are two very different things. I can understand why someone did something without believing that what they did was right. I can recognize the experiences that shaped a person without excusing the decisions they ultimately made. I can look at someone and say, "What you did was inexcusable and cannot be defended, but I understand why you did it." Understanding is not absolution. It is context.
Writing fiction has reinforced that lesson for me. A novel gives readers time and context that real life rarely provides. It allows us to see the experiences, relationships and decisions that shape a character before we judge them. My latest novel, Blood Rivalry, gave me an opportunity to explore that idea through characters whose choices may be difficult to understand or defend. The point is not to excuse those choices but to show how context can change the way we understand the person who made them.
Understanding Is Not Agreement
I also believe we have started treating compromise as capitulation. If I understand your position, I must secretly support it. If I ask why you believe something, I must be defending you. If I acknowledge the circumstances behind someone's behavior, I must be excusing it. I don't accept that. We can disagree profoundly and still make the effort to understand one another. In fact, I would argue that understanding makes meaningful disagreement possible. If I do not understand what you actually believe, then I am not really disagreeing with you. I am disagreeing with the version of your position that I have constructed in my own mind.
I don't think fiction can solve America's divisions. A novel cannot repair every broken friendship or turn every political disagreement into consensus. But I do believe fiction can exercise a muscle that our current culture rarely asks us to use. It can teach us to stay with another person's story. It can teach us to resist the urge to judge immediately. It can remind us that people are almost always more complicated than the position they express or the mistake they have made. Most importantly, it can remind us that understanding someone does not require agreeing with them.
I don't want an America without disagreement. I want an America that can disagree without losing the ability to listen. We do not have to abandon our convictions. We do not have to excuse behavior we believe is wrong. We do not have to pretend that every position deserves equal merit. But before we decide who someone is, I believe we should make the effort to understand who they are. That requires something our current culture does not always reward: patience. It requires us to ask another question instead of immediately delivering another answer. It requires us to listen when we would rather speak.
The next time someone says something we strongly disagree with, we can choose not to answer immediately. We can ask one more question. We can listen for another minute. We can try to understand the experience behind the belief before deciding what we think about the person who holds it.
Paul Attaway is a novelist and author of the Atkins Family Low Country Saga. He earned his law degree from the University of Georgia School of Law and spent more than 30 years as a business entrepreneur before turning to fiction. His latest novel, Blood Rivalry, is the third book in the series.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines