
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Americans have repeatedly been told that the current housing affordability crisis has been the result of a longstanding shortage of homes, as not enough properties were built after the Great Recession.
Affordability has been strained so much that the U.S. housing market risks incurring into a paradox soon, according to a new study: in less than 10 years time, the nation could have too many homes.
In a recently published paper, three researchers at the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) argue that "the post-financial crisis narrative of a persistent housing shortage may no longer accurately describe market conditions over the decades ahead."
Read More on News
If construction remains high and demand constrained due to ongoing affordability issues, supply growth could outpace demand by 2035, they say.
How Could the US Suddenly Have Too Many Homes?
While exact numbers differ, the current housing shortage is estimated to be between 1.5 million and 7.3 million units, according to MBA. J.P. Morgan puts it between 3 million and 10 million units.
It is a major gap between supply and demand across the country, though things are not as simple as they sound: while parts of the country like the Northeast and Midwest are still facing acute shortages driving up prices, other parts like the South and the West have plenty of inventory.

...
States like Florida and Texas, facing a huge influx of newcomers during the pandemic, built more new homes than any other in the years following the start of the health emergency. In these states, prices have already adjusted significantly.
And yet, this gap could vanish in less than 10 years, MBA researchers argue.
"In the recent period, vacancy rates climbed, rent growth stalled, and for-sale inventories rose. These trends were most pronounced in Sun Belt markets," study authors Mike Fratantoni, Joel Kan, Judie Ricks and Edward Seiler write.
A combination of new construction projects—started in the wake of the outcry against the current affordability crisis—and demographic trends pointing downward—an aging population as well as slower population growth—suggest that demand, already dwindling, might actually plunge in the U.S.
"Household formation is expected to slow over the next decade due to population aging, low fertility rates, smaller younger adult cohorts, and reduced immigration," MBA researchers say.
"Aging baby boomers are unlikely to flood the market with inventory, but home transfers will moderately add to supply over time. If construction remains elevated, supply growth could outpace demand growth," they add.
"These trends carry meaningful implications for homeowners and the mortgage industry, including risks to origination volumes, borrower equity, and credit performance."
What Does This Mean for Homebuyers—And Homeowners?
An oversupply of homes for sale in the U.S. housing market would have one obvious consequence: push down prices. For buyers, this would be great news. They have already gained significant negotiating power over the past year, as the imbalance between sellers and buyers in the market tilted heavily in favor of the second.
If prices were to fall further, many more would-be buyers who have been waiting for an improvement in affordability over the past few years would be able to return to the market and make a purchase. And those who do not currently have enough savings for a down payment on their first or dream home might be able to afford it if values fall.
For homeowners, on the other hand, it is not as good a prospect. It is likely that their homes would fall in value and they would lose some of the staggering equity they have gained over the pandemic.
A twist towards oversupply could have a ripple effect on other sectors as well. Eric Bernstein, president and co-founder, LendFriend Mortgage, told Newsweek a potential shift toward oversupply would reshape the mortgage market in ways most buyers aren’t thinking about yet.
"When home values plateau or soften, lenders tighten standards on conventional loans—but the borrowers who feel it most are self-employed buyers and real estate investors who already rely on non-qualified mortgage products like bank statement loans and asset depletion financing," Bernstein said.
"Ironically, a surplus market can make it harder, not easier, to get a deal done if your income doesn’t fit a standard W-2 mold," he added. "Buyers with complex financial profiles need to be positioning themselves now, before any shift in market sentiment changes what lenders are willing to approve."
Ironically, This Might Not Be the Solution to the Crisis
Commenting on the stagnation of the U.S. population, experts told Newsweek that the U.S. home supply shortage is too severe to be fixed so quickly. (The population grew by 1.8 million people, or 0.5 percent, between July 2024 and July 2025, according to the Population Estimates Program (PEP), down from 3.2 million a year earlier.)
The main concern is that in states where inventory remains tight, home prices will continue rising, while they might plunge into those that already have a significant supply—reinforcing the current regional divide. And that the current shortage of affordable homes would survive price declines.
"What we have now is this serious loss of lower-cost housing, housing that’s affordable to people at the kind of lower and/or middle income of the distribution," Alexander Hermann, a senior research associate at Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies, told Newsweek.
In effect, a wave of new supply does not, by itself, rebalance the market. If overall housing supply improves, that does not automatically mean new units will be built at price points these lower or middle-income households can afford.
"You’re not going to change that mismatch in what’s affordable to households at these different income levels," he said.
Update, 7/1/2026 6:35 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include a comment from Eric Bernstein.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines