Air marshal border comp

...

Dan Gooding

By Dan Gooding

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A passenger who confronted an aggressive man on a flight left without an air marshal, due to redeployments to the U.S.-Mexico border, has told Newsweek it was "complete chaos" that could have ended very differently.

Gretchün Ciluzzi was on a United flight with her mother in March 2023 when a man allegedly tried to open an emergency door, before becoming aggressive towards the crew and passengers in a terrifying incident lasting well over an hour.

The Air Marshal National Council claims that airline passengers are being left unprotected while its members are sent to work on a mission for which they are not trained — immigration enforcement along the southwest border.

Read More on News

"I knew that we were in trouble when the flight attendant came over to ask somebody if they had tried to open an emergency door," Ciluzzi said. "I am not a professional, I haven't been trained in those types of situations, but it did not make any sense to me.

"If somebody is saying 'where is the air marshal? Just shoot me down right now', if nobody is even going to use their voice to calm this person down, I knew nobody was on the plane and that's why I got up."

Air marshal border comp

...

Ciluzzi, 51, was flying from Los Angeles with her mother and, despite being a nervous flyer, felt she had to act when the man became aggressive.

She was seen in videos of the incident interacting with him, asking him to stop as he was scaring people.

"Why I did stand up first is because I was really thinking we were going to die," she told Newsweek.

Air marshals at the border

Often in situations like this, an air marshal would step in, but the AMNC told Newsweek that many flights have gone unprotected because agents are instead at the southwest border, helping to boost border patrol numbers.

"It's demeaning," one marshal, speaking to Newsweek on condition of anonymity, said after multiple postings to the border.

"As a trained federal agent... then to be treated in [this] manner. The agents themselves aren't treating us badly, it's the administration that has put us in this position."

The AMNC, which represents air marshals across the United States, argues that its members' job is not at the border carrying out "menial tasks," but in the air protecting passengers.

The deployments began in 2019, first on a voluntary basis before TSA bosses made the rotations part of regular operations.

"The problem we had was when they came up with forced deployments and they were taking 200 air marshals every 21 days and forcing them to go to the border," Sonya Hightower-LaBosco, the AMNC's executive director, told Newsweek.

CBP Stock image

...

Some air marshals have completed three rotations at the border, which Hightower-LaBosco argues means they are taken off high-risk flights.

When they are stationed at the border alongside U.S. Customs and Border Protection, air marshals are carrying out perimeter checks, unloading supplies including diapers, and handing out food and water.

"The area that I was at had less than one person coming across the border per hour, for the six of us that were there at the station," the anonymous marshal added. "So we are sitting there for eight to ten hours doing absolutely nothing.

"There is no reason for us to have been there."

The marshal said he felt that he and his colleagues were being used to fill gaps while border patrol officers took breaks or vacation, or even filed paperwork.

TSA unable to assess success

While Republican lawmakers introduced legislation earlier this year to bring marshals back from the southwest border, some have still had further deployments with U.S. Customs and Border Protection in recent weeks.

The ad hoc scheme has since cost CBP around $45 million in reimbursements for travel and overtime pay, according to a report from the Department of Homeland Security's Inspector General in early July.

In the report, it was stated that no targets or tangible goals were set when the redeployments began, so it was not possible to measure whether sending air marshals to the border had been a success.

Heavily redacted sections of the report covered up charts on air marshal coverage of commercial flights, but without the performance measures, the IG said it "could not corroborate the conflicting assertions on whether Southwest border deployments adversely impacted in-flight mission coverage."

Airline passengers put at-risk

Plane cabin stock image

...

Hightower-LaBosco said the safety of both the U.S. border and airline passengers were being compromised as a result.

"It's a lose-lose situation," she told Newsweek. "It's a loss for the individual without the proper training, it's a loss for the travelers who pay a pretty high price for a security fee on their airline tickets."

Ciluzzi said she experienced this firsthand, as passengers cried in distress as the man on her flight stepped into the aisle and made jabbing motions at those around him.

While cabin crew tried to restrain him, he busted out of the zip ties.

"There was a woman who was standing right where [he] was being tackled and he actually tried to bite her toes," Ciluzzi added.

It wasn't until the plane landed and police boarded that the disruptive passenger was properly restrained and arrested.

Reports of passenger aggression on board flights have been on the rise in recent years, with Republican lawmakers seeking to make changes earlier this year by introducing the "No FAMs at the Border Act".

"Americans have recently witnessed numerous high-profile security incidents in the sky, highlighting that TSA's decision to take air marshals off flights and deploy them to the border may be putting the traveling public at risk," Senator Ted Cruz said in March.

"In a brazen act of hypocrisy, the Biden administration maintains that the border is secure, while it continues to reassign air marshals from protecting the skies to the southern border."

A spokesperson for the TSA told Newsweek that the redeployments have not had an effect on security operations, and that the numbers of air marshals stationed at the border have gone down since the Biden administration sharply curtailed record migrant arrivals with an executive action last month.

"As a result of the President's recent Executive Order, Federal Air Marshal deployments to the Southwest Border (SWB) have been reduced, commensurate with the reduced number of encounters at the SWB. Federal Air Marshals deployed to the SWB perform a variety of law enforcement duties in support of our CBP partners," the spokesperson said.

But Hightower-LaBosco said that DHS needed to do more to have conversations on changing up the current practice and, as she put it, to keep Americans safe.

For Ciluzzi, she could not leave her house for a time after the mid-flight scare, and she struggled with anxiety medication. It took her some time before she felt able to fly again.

"I wish I could tell you that I felt safer... but I don't," she said.

Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines