10

Loading video...

Ewan Palmer

By Ewan Palmer

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The judge overseeing Donald Trump's classified documents trial may still have benefited the former president despite rejecting one of his motions to dismiss the case, legal experts have suggested.

On Thursday, Judge Aileen Cannon issued an order that threw out Trump's legal team's claim the charges related to the Espionage Act are "unconstitutionally vague" when applied to the former president, and should be struck down.

In her two-page ruling Cannon, who was nominated to the bench by Trump, said that the motion brings up "various arguments warranting serious consideration," but that Trump's concerns about the Espionage Act should be brought up in "connection with jury-instruction briefing."

Read More

Donald Trump Dealt a Blow in Classified Documents Case3 min read

Donald Trump Dealt a Blow in Classified Documents Case

Jack Smith’s Two Options if Aileen Cannon Dismisses Trump Charges4 min read

Jack Smith’s Two Options if Aileen Cannon Dismisses Trump Charges

Why Donald Trump Critic Is Hoping Aileen Cannon Dismisses Trump’s Case3 min read

Why Donald Trump Critic Is Hoping Aileen Cannon Dismisses Trump’s Case

Despite her ruling against the former president, legal analysts said that Cannon may still have helped Trump by suggesting his legal team could bring up their arguments again in the future, and that the hearing itself caused an unnecessary delay in the proceedings.

Donald Trump in Virginia

...

Speaking to MSNBC, former FBI General Counsel Andrew Weissmann said that Cannon's decision was the "worst possible outcome" for Special Counsel Jack's Smith team.

"If the judge had simply said, 'I agree with Donald Trump, and I find that this is vague and I'm dismissing it,' the government could have appealed it to the Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, as they have done twice before and won twice before," Weissmann said.

"But she also did not want to rule in favor of the government. So what she did is said 'why don't you bring this up later? I think there's some real issues here.'

"By kicking it down the road and saying 'but I still may decide in Donald Trump's favor later,' she has sort of avoided the sword of Damocles over the 11th circuit," Weissman added.

Neal Katyal, a lawyer and former acting U.S. solicitor general during the Obama administration, also told MSNBC that Cannon still gave Trump what he wanted by potentially delaying the start of the trial, currently scheduled for May 20, holding an all-day motion to dismiss the hearing in the first place.

Trump, the presumptive 2024 Republican nominee, has long faced accusations he is trying to delay the federal trial until after the election.

If Trump beats President Joe Biden in November before the classified documents trial takes place, Trump could then order the Department of Justice to drop the federal case into him once he enters office.

"My fear is that this is going to be a win for Jack Smith in the same way as the win will be once the Supreme Court decides the absolute immunity case that they're hearing on April 25," Katyal said.

"I think there's no chance the Supreme Court is going to side with Trump on absolute immunity. But the court having such a delayed schedule gave Donald Trump what he wants, which is a very realistic possibility you can delay the case past the election. That's basically what Cannon has done here by kicking the can down the road."

A similar argument was also made by Ohio-based attorney Jeff Roush in a series of posts on X, formerly Twitter.

"If Cannon had ruled in Trump's favor and dismissed the case, it would have gone right to the 11th Circuit. Based on what we've seen when she's been overruled before, they would have been quick and decisive—much more so than this denial for now," Roush wrote.

"So rather than give a firm ruling on a clear issue, Cannon's quasi-denial amounts to a delay that opens the door to more delay later. Every bit of it inures to Trump's benefit by keeping decisions out of the hands of more serious judges."

Trump's legal team has been contacted for comment via email.

Cannon did not issue a ruling on a second motion filed by Trump's team arguing that the Presidential Records Act allows Trump to designate the documents he took after leaving the White House his own personal property, and thus he cannot be charged with their unauthorized possession.

The judge hinted that she will also reject this motion. During the hearing Cannon said it would be "difficult" to justify tossing out the case before it went to a jury over the former president's Presidential Records Act argument.

Cannon is also expected to confirm that the trial will be pushed back from its current start date of May 20.

Trump's lawyers had previously argued the classified documents trial should not take place until 2025 due to the Republican's campaign schedule. Trump's lawyers also suggested a potential August start date, as required by a court order. Smith's team told Cannon that the trial should take place in July.

Trump has pleaded not guilty to 40 charges over allegations he illegally retained sensitive materials when he left the White House in January 2021 and then obstructed the federal attempts to retrieve them.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines