Judge Aileen Cannon’s suppression of Trump Mar-a-Lago documents is under scrutiny. She is shown here testifying virtually during her nomination hearing to the Senate Judiciary Committee in Washington, on July 29, 2020. (Senate Judiciary Committee via AP)

...

Robert Alexander

By Robert Alexander

Senior Crime & Court Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Lawyers at the Knight First Amendment Institute have asked a court to decide whether to release a long-hidden report on President Donald Trump’s handling of classified records.

The Columbia University institute, which works to defend and expand freedom of speech and the press, asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit to order a federal trial court to rule on the release, following the collapse of the criminal case that produced the report.

The classified documents case against Trump was dismissed by U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon in July, 2024, after she agreed with the defense's argument that special counsel Jack Smith, who filed charges against Trump, was illegally appointed by the Justice Department.

Read More on U.S.

Smith had accused the president of illegally hoarding classified records at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Florida, and obstructing FBI efforts to get them back. Trump had pleaded not guilty and denied wrongdoing.

In its petition for a writ of mandamus, filed Tuesday, the Knight Institute argued that the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida has "manifestly unreasonable[ly]" delayed ruling on a motion the group filed in February seeking public access to what it calls a document of extraordinary public importance—“Volume II" of Smith’s report on the classified documents case.

Newsweek contacted the Special Counsel and two of the President’s attorneys for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Tuesday.

Why It Matters

The dispute over releasing Special Counsel Jack Smith’s still-sealed report on Donald Trump’s handling of classified records is about more than one document. At its core, the Knight First Amendment Institute’s appeal tests whether courts can indefinitely withhold rulings that block public access to judicial records in politically sensitive cases.

The outcome could shape how much the public learns about the Justice Department’s handling of investigations into presidents, how the Espionage Act is interpreted, and whether future administrations can keep major investigative findings secret once prosecutions end.

Judge Aileen Cannon’s suppression of Trump Mar-a-Lago documents is under scrutiny. She is shown here testifying virtually during her nomination hearing to the Senate Judiciary Committee in Washington, on July 29, 2020. (Senate Judiciary Committee via AP)

...

What To Know

The Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University is a nonpartisan nonprofit organization that uses litigation, research, and advocacy to defend and advance the freedoms of speech and the press, particularly in the digital age.

Their September 30, 2025, filing underscores how the collapse of the Justice Department’s prosecution of Trump in the classified documents matter has left unresolved questions about whether the investigative record will ever become public.

Background on the Report and Litigation

The Special Counsel investigation began after the FBI opened a criminal probe in March 2022 into Trump’s retention of classified material at Mar-a-Lago.

Attorney General Merrick Garland appointed Smith on November 18, 2022, to oversee that inquiry and a separate January 6 investigation.

Smith’s team secured a 37-count indictment in June 2023, including 31 alleged violations of the Espionage Act. Prosecutors said Trump stored sensitive military and intelligence documents at Mar-a-Lago, shared some with unauthorized individuals, and obstructed federal efforts to recover them. Trump pleaded not guilty and denied any wrongdoing.

Two aides—Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira—were also charged as co-conspirators. They also pleaded not guilty

But the criminal case unraveled.

On July 15, 2024, Trump-appointed Cannon dismissed the superseding indictment, finding Smith’s appointment as special counsel unconstitutional.

Smith appealed but later dropped the effort after Trump’s November 2024 election victory, citing longstanding Justice Department policy against prosecuting a sitting president.

On January 21, 2025, Judge Cannon entered an order barring public release of Volume II, saying it was necessary to protect defendants’ due process and fair trial rights.

But by February 2025, the government had ended proceedings against Nauta and De Oliveira and said it had ‘no intent to revive the charges.

Former President Donald Trump speaks at Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster, N.J., Tuesday, June 13, 2023, after pleading not guilty in a Miami courtroom earlier in the day to dozens of felony counts that he hoarded classified documents and refused government demands to give them back. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)

...

Freedom Of Information Refused

The Knight Institute first sought disclosure through the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), but the Justice Department refused, citing Judge Cannon’s January 21 order.

The Institute then filed a motion to intervene in the criminal case to lift the injunction and post the report on the public docket. Its February motion argued the report is a "judicial record" subject to common law and First Amendment rights of access because it was submitted to the court in connection with defense emergency motions.

In March, the Institute responded to government and defense objections, asserting that intervention was proper and timely because the injunction directly blocks FOIA rights and because no defendant faces further legal jeopardy. "Ex-Defendants’ efforts to paint Volume II as ‘unreliable’ is nothing more than a denial of the allegations," the Institute’s reply brief said, arguing that such objections cannot override the presumption of public access.

Despite those filings, the district court has not ruled, prompting Monday’s mandamus petition.

Legal Basis for the Petition

The Knight Institute’s September 30 filing tells the Eleventh Circuit that it has "no other adequate means" to obtain relief because an interlocutory appeal is unavailable.

The group says its "entitlement to the writ is clear and indisputable" under precedents recognizing the public’s right to access judicial records and courts’ duty to rule on properly presented motions.

The petition cites Supreme Court and appellate decisions on mandamus relief, including Cheney v. U.S. District Court and Newman v. Graddick, to argue that extraordinary delay in ruling can justify appellate intervention.

It contends that keeping the report sealed serves no ongoing legal interest now that charges have been dropped and statutes of limitations would bar re-prosecution of the dismissed defendants.

Broader Context

Volume II’s contents have not been made public, but court filings indicate Volume II is the Special Counsel’s report addressing the investigation into Trump’s handling of classified material and the Espionage Act.

The Institute argues disclosure would help the public understand how the Justice Department approached unprecedented allegations against a president and then sitting president-elect, and how it interpreted a key national security statute with implications for press freedom.

The dispute follows earlier efforts by transparency groups to access investigative materials about presidents. For example, the National Archives has previously released under FOIA draft indictments and legal memos from Independent Counsels concerning President Bill Clinton, subject to redactions for grand jury secrecy.

The Knight Institute contends similar transparency principles apply here and said in its September 30 press release that "the public’s right to know what the Justice Department found and how it interpreted the law cannot be indefinitely delayed."

What People Are Saying

Scott Wilkens, Senior Counsel, Knight First Amendment Institute in its September 30 petition: "The court’s monthslong delay in ruling on our motion for the release of the Special Counsel’s report has the same effect as denying the motion outright."

Jameel Jaffer, Executive Director, Knight First Amendment Institute, in the group’s press statement accompanying the petition: "There is no legitimate reason for the report’s continued suppression, and it should be posted on the court’s public docket without further delay."

What Happens Next

The Eleventh Circuit must now decide whether to grant the Knight First Amendment Institute’s request for a writ of mandamus. If granted, the appeals court would require Judge Aileen Cannon to rule on whether to keep or lift the seal on Special Counsel Jack Smith’s report about Donald Trump’s classified records case; if denied, the report remains sealed until the district court acts on its own.

The court could also seek additional briefing or hold arguments before ruling, and any decision could be appealed further. Should the seal be lifted, the report would undergo a review for necessary redactions before any public release.

The Justice Department has not opposed the Institute’s right to intervene but has argued some information should stay sealed, while Trump’s former co-defendants have opposed disclosure.

As of Tuesday, neither the department nor Trump’s attorneys had publicly commented on the new appellate filing.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines