
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When the Senate Banking Committee called Kevin Warsh to testify on April 21 as President Donald Trump’s nominee to chair the Federal Reserve, the hearing was billed as a fight over whether politicians were trying to take over the central bank.
The fear stems from a little-challenged assumption that flows beneath all discussions about the Federal Reserve: its independence is a sacred economic law.
Trump has triggered acute sensitivity about Fed independence, not often in any real doubt, with his unorthodox approach to monetary policy for a U.S. president.
Read More on Analysis
Ever the disruptor, Trump marched right across the old mores to bellow repeatedly, and barbed with insults, his views on interest rates and Jerome Powell’s handling of policy as chairman of the Fed’s Board of Governors, a role he is due to leave in May.
But the pressure campaign against Powell went beyond verbal admonishment by the president, which included opaque threats to fire him, and into the realm of lawfare.
Powell said in January that the Justice Department had served grand-jury subpoenas on the Fed for a construction project that was running over budget. Trump’s attempt to fire Fed Governor Lisa Cook is with the Supreme Court, which is tilting against the president.
But the theatrics of this Trumpian spectacle obscure a more profound question about the Federal Reserve’s independence.
Does a doctrine designed for the late-20th-century global order still make sense for a country trying to build more housing, more power, and more industrial capacity at home?
1. Independence Was Invented for a Particular Historical Problem
Modern Fed independence did not descend from the heavens. It emerged from a specific postwar fight over inflation and debt management that culminated in the 1951 Treasury-Fed Accord.
Before that deal, the Fed had spent years helping finance World War II by keeping short-term Treasury rates pegged at ⅜ percent.
It was a policy that made sense during total war but became harder to defend once inflation accelerated in peacetime, as the Federal Reserve’s own history explains.
The independence settlement that followed was a solution to that problem: how to stop elected officials from leaning on the central bank to keep government borrowing cheap when prices were already running hot.
That was a real and consequential achievement that suited the needs of the moment. But it was still a historical bargain, not a timeless commandment.
A rule built for an era defined by excess demand, oil shocks, and the policing of inflation may not fit one defined by shortages of homes, grid capacity, and domestic industrial supply, a shift laid out in the Trump administration’s 2026 Trade Policy Agenda.
2. Congress Created Fed Independence, and Congress Can Redefine It
The legal structure of Fed independence is strong, but it is plainly statutory.
The Federal Reserve Act gives governors 14-year terms, gives the chair a separate four-year designation, and says board members may be removed only "for cause," which is why a president cannot simply wake up one morning and treat the Fed chair like a Cabinet secretary.
But the same Federal Reserve Act also makes clear that the institution is a creation of Congress, which means Congress can revise its powers, rewrite its mandate, and alter its governance.
The Fed has operational independence. But it does not have independence over its goals. The modern dual mandate of maximum employment and stable prices became law only in 1977.
Even Warsh argued in 2010 that independence is not an excuse for unaccountability but a form of credibility that has to be earned.
Too many defenders of the status quo miss this point. Treating Fed independence as revisable is not radicalism; it is an acknowledgment of how the institution was built in the first place.
3. Coordination Can Work Better Than Technocratic Distance
The strongest argument against turning central banking into a priesthood is empirical rather than ideological.
During the pandemic recession, the U.S. avoided a depression in part because Congress and the Fed acted at the same time and at great speed.
It is a combination that Brookings scholars credit with producing a faster and stronger recovery than most forecasts expected.
In a later cross-country assessment, Brookings argued that the U.S. outperformed other G10 economies in growth and investment even as later inflation was driven heavily by supply disruptions and housing scarcity.
None of that proves coordination is always wise, and the 1970s experience documented in a Journal of Economic Perspectives paper using the Nixon tapes remains a warning about political pressure for easy money ahead of elections.
But it does show that the default story—politicians distort, technocrats save—has always been too neat.
In moments of national mobilization, from the wartime peg to the pandemic response, the American state has often worked best when fiscal and monetary authorities were complements rather than rivals.
4. An Abundance Economy Needs Cheaper, Longer-Term Capital
The central economic problem in the U.S. today is that supply has been starved for years. Yes, demand can run too hot, and that is a concern to be mitigated. But there is a deepening and more urgent capacity problem gripping the country.
The White House's own 2026 Economic Report of the President says that if homebuilding had continued at its historical pace after 2008, the country would now have "10 million or more" additional single-family homes, a staggering measure of scarcity.
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory says there were about 10,300 projects actively seeking grid interconnection at the end of 2024, representing around 1,400 gigawatts of generation and roughly 890 gigawatts of storage, which is another way of saying that capacity is waiting in line.
Fed Vice Chair Philip Jefferson has acknowledged that housing is among the most interest-rate-sensitive sectors of the economy and that restrictive policy has weighed on the housing market.
An Oxford sustainable finance study found that higher rates pushed nominal borrowing costs for North American solar and wind projects from under 2 percent in 2022 to almost 8 percent in 2024, increasing their costs more sharply than for gas generation.
In that environment, a persistently restrictive central bank can do more than cool inflation.
It can also raise the cost of expanding the housing, energy, and infrastructure capacity needed to bring inflation down sustainably and create the economy of abundance Americans are yearning for.
An abundance economy, in other words, requires not only stronger supply but cheaper, longer-term capital to finance it.
5. The Post-Globalist Era Is Changing the Logic of Independence
Fed independence rose alongside a broader worldview in which trade was meant to stay open, capital was meant to move freely, supply chains were meant to span the globe, and technocratic institutions were meant to smooth the edges.
That worldview is now under direct challenge.
The administration’s 2026 Trade Policy Agenda says flatly that the U.S. should "produce more of what it consumes" and condemns decades of "debt-driven consumption divorced from domestic production."
Recent White House tariff actions on metals are explicitly framed around domestic capacity, supply-chain security, and strategic production rather than around the old assumption that globalization would solve those questions on its own.
Once the state decides that building ships, fans, transmission, housing, and energy infrastructure is a core national objective, monetary policy stops looking like a neutral referee standing outside the development model. It becomes part of the model.
Of course, that does not mean the White House should dictate rate decisions from the Resolute desk.
It means the older separation between industrial strategy, fiscal capacity, and central-bank discretion is going to look less natural the more Washington commits itself to a politics of abundance.
Honest Change
That's why Trump's method of upending Fed independence is so much worse than the issue he is clumsily trying to raise.
Warsh, Trump's nominee, warned in 2010 that "there is no such thing as being a little bit independent or a little bit credible," and that point still stands.
A president who wants a different Fed has lawful tools available through nomination, legislation, and an honest public argument about the mandate. Public threats and dubious legal pressure are not a legitimate reform agenda.
Fed independence is not sacred. There are good arguments against it. But changing it by intimidation would be worse than defending it by superstition.
Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.
As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines