10

Loading video...

Sean O'Driscoll

By Sean O'Driscoll

Senior Crime and Courts Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A dissent by Justice Amy Coney Barrett in a case concerning President Donald Trump's use of a wartime-era deportation law has triggered a wave of backlash from prominent conservative commentators and online supporters of the president.

Barrett, appointed to the Supreme Court by Trump in 2020, joined the Court's three liberal justices in opposing the majority's decision to allow the administration to continue deporting alleged gang members under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. In her dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor warned that the Trump administration's conduct "poses an extraordinary threat to the rule of law."

While the unsigned majority opinion allowed the deportations to continue for now, it ruled that individuals must be given a chance to challenge their removal under due process—a point the American Civil Liberties Union also claimed as a victory. Trump, meanwhile, hailed the decision as "a great day for justice in America."

Read More

Judge Boasberg Suggests Potential Contempt Hearings With Trump Admin3 min read

Judge Boasberg Suggests Potential Contempt Hearings With Trump Admin

Judge Boasberg Faces Removal Under New GOP Proposal3 min read

Judge Boasberg Faces Removal Under New GOP Proposal

Donald Trump Says He Loves Idea of Sending Americans to El Salvador Prison5 min read

Donald Trump Says He Loves Idea of Sending Americans to El Salvador Prison

Was Amy Coney Barrett Trump’s Greatest Mistake?

...

Online backlash was swift. Conservative influencer Rogan O'Handley, known as DC_Draino, wrote on X (former Twitter): "While this Supreme Court victory for Trump allowing him to deport cartels is huge, it was only a 5-4 decision. Guess who joined the 3 liberal Justices to keep cartels here in America? Amy Coney Barrett."

Major MAGA figure Catturd, who has 3.6 million followers on X, posted: "There's nobody I have less respect for in the entire country besides Dr. Fauci than Amy Commie Barrett - Trump appointed her and gave her her dream job and complimented her and praised her - and she's been an ungrateful, backstabbing POS since day one. She got a million dollar Liberal book deal within weeks and her whole goal in Life is to be praised by The New York Times.

The post added: "Weak, coward, sellout, fraud. She's everything that's wrong with this country. She's an Absolute disgusting fraud."

MAGA poster Kim 'Katie' USA, a Vietnam-born conservative, wrote on X in response to the decision: "Appointing a woman, namely Amy Coney Barrett, was a huge mistake."

One of her followers replied: "The bigger issue is that Barrett hates Trump."

Conservative commentator Jeff Younger wrote on X: "All the men on the Court voted the law. All the women, including Amy Coney Barrett, voted their feelings."

Another conservative commentator, Angela Belcamino, wrote on X: "We can all agree that no one likes Supreme Court Justice, Amy Coney Barrett... Am I correct?"

One of her followers replied: "She seems to be a wolf in sheep's wool kinda gal doesn't she? I'm not sure if she is being led by a dislike of Trump or really was able to get herself branded as a constitutionalist when she really wasn't."

What People Are Saying

Sonia Sotomayor, who wrote the dissenting opinion, was joined by Ketanji Brown Jackson and Elena Kagan, but joined only in part by Amy Coney Barrett.

In the part to which Coney Barrett was willing to put her name, Sotomayor sharply criticized the Supreme Court majority for taking the case on an emergency basis, and for overruling a Washington, D.C., district court judge, James Boasberg, who had halted the deportations.

"If the District Court were to resolve the question in plaintiffs' favor, the Government could have appealed to this Court in the ordinary course, and we could have decided it after thorough briefing and oral argument," Sotomayor wrote.

"In its rush to decide the issue now, the Court halts the lower court's work and forces us to decide the matter after mere days of deliberation and without adequate time to weigh the parties' arguments or the full record of the District Court's proceedings."

PDF

477870-supreme-court-deportations.pdf.PDF

Download

What Happens Next

The case returns to the district court in Washington, D.C. With the Supreme Court accepting that Trump can use the Alien Enemies Act, the government is in a much stronger position.

However, the court also recognized that everyone facing deportation under the Alien Enemies Act must be granted a court hearing, a fact warmly welcomed by Sotomayor in her dissenting opinion.

That means that Boasberg may be able to order the return of the deported men for a hearing in the United States.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines