Elephant Butte Reservoir

...

Mandy Taheri

By Mandy Taheri

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday ruled on a case regarding a decades-long water allocation dispute among Colorado, New Mexico and Texas. In his dissenting opinion, Justice Neil Gorsuch, who sided with the states, said the court's decision, "defies 100 years of this Court's water law jurisprudence."

Texas v. New Mexico and Colorado is about state water rights related to the Rio Grande, a crucial water source that flows through all three states and provides water to roughly 6 million people. The dispute revolves around the 1938 Rio Grande Compact, which determined how the states were to share the river's water.

In a 5-4 decision released on Friday, the court rejected a 2022 proposed settlement (consent decree) between Texas and New Mexico, ruling that the settlement would have resolved the federal government's claims without its consent, meaning the federal government was not included and did not agree to the terms of the settlement in the case that was brought in 2013.

Read More

Lauren Boebert Lawsuit Update3 min read

Lauren Boebert Lawsuit Update

Tucker Carlson’s Viral Confrontation With Reporter Cheered by Conservatives6 min read

Tucker Carlson’s Viral Confrontation With Reporter Cheered by Conservatives

Lauren Boebert Win Rebuked in Colorado Newspaper: ‘Carpetbagging Canoodler’3 min read

Lauren Boebert Win Rebuked in Colorado Newspaper: ‘Carpetbagging Canoodler’

Elephant Butte Reservoir

...

Harvard law professor Andrew Mergen said in a March interview with Harvard Law Today that the compact includes the three states as parties, but "there is also a treaty obligation on the part of the United States to deliver a quantity of the river's water to Mexico," and "it also acknowledges the duty to Indian tribes, who also have an interest in this water."

In 2018, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government can join the case as a party. Mergen said the reason the U.S. wanted to get involved in the case in 2018 was "because of its obligations to Mexico," and that "water is delivered in part through a reclamation project."

On Friday, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson penned the majority opinion, writing: "Our decision today follows directly from our prior recognition of the United States' distinct federal interests in the Rio Grande Compact," referring to the 2018 case. "Having acknowledged those interests, and having allowed the United States to intervene to assert them, we cannot now allow Texas and New Mexico to leave the United States up the river without a paddle."

Texas brought the case against New Mexico because of the state's allegedly excessive groundwater pumping which has depleted the amount of surface water reaching Texas. According to the compact, "New Mexico must deliver a certain amount of water to the Elephant Butte Reservoir," which the Federal Bureau of Reclamation operates, releasing specified amounts for delivery in other New Mexico districts and Texas.

In his dissenting opinion, Gorsuch, joined by Justices Thomas, Alito and Barrett, sided with the states, writing: "The decree would fairly apportion water from the Rio Grande River between those two States and leave federal reclamation operations in the area running the way they have run for decades." He noted that Special Master Michael Melloy, whom the court appointed in 2018, approved of the proposed decree.

In 2023, Melloy, a federal circuit court judge, found the proposed consent decree to be "fair, reasonable, and consistent with the Compact," as described in the New Mexico Department of Justice's press release.

"The Court's decision is inconsistent with how original jurisdiction cases normally proceed," Gorsuch said in his opinion, adding, "It defies 100 years of this Court's water law jurisprudence. And it represents a serious assault on the power of States to govern, as they always have, the water rights of users in their jurisdictions. The Special Master issued a detailed 115-page report laying all this out. His views were wise, his recommendations sound, and, respectfully, we should have done as he suggested."

He added: "Over the better part of a century, this arrangement has worked reasonably well," referring to the 1938 Rio Grande Compact. "Yes, disagreements occasionally arise, sometimes leading to the filing of a complaint in this Court. But, invariably, these disputes have settled before the Court reached the merits."

Mergen told Newsweek in an emailed statement: "I think the Court reached the right result. I think as a matter of procedure the Court is correct that this case cannot be settled without the United States which had previously been allowed by the Court to intervene," in reference to the 2018 case.

The case comes at a time when climate change and rising temperatures have heavily impacted water levels. Mergen noted this in his statement, saying: "Climate change and water scarcity guarantee more litigation in the future."

Neil Gorsuch

...

In a follow-up phone interview, Mergen said that "states regulate water quantity" while the federal government, through the Clean Water Act, deals with water quality.

"I think the Court's decision is a net positive for the resolution of these kinds of disputes because the federal government often has responsibilities to foreign governments [Mexico in this case], to Indian tribes along interstate rivers and Congress has also charged the federal government, with among other things, the preservation of endangered species many of which are aquatic," he said.

He noted that while some of the aspects might not be directly implicated in this case, they might be in other "interstate stream issues."

"With respect, I think the dissent discounts the federal role here," Mergen said, adding that "I think Justice Gorsuch oversimplifies to reach that conclusion."

This is an original jurisdiction case, which means "it did not come up to the court in the normal way," Mergen said. "Original actions are handled by a Special Master appointed by the Court. Now, this case will go back to the Special Master," he said, adding that it is possible the case returns to the Supreme Court at some point.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines